Smoke Wagon Uncut Unfiltered Vs. Old Ezra 7yr Barrel Proof

Smoke Wagon Old Ezra - 1.jpeg

So I’m not sure what made me do this comparison other than the fact that I knew I liked both, are both similar proofs, not too far apart in price, and both nice-looking bottles.
Fancy Glencairn can’t resist the over-the-top fanciness of the Smoke Wagon bottle… Let’s see if that makes her a winner!

Old Ezra) ~ $50, 117proof.
-The Nose starts with ethanol heat, then leather, brown sugar, cinnamon, and corn.
-The Palate also starts hot, but then full flavors appear of oak, vanilla, and dark-fruits like cherry and figs. Maybe a little anise in there as well.
-The finish is fairly long, but somewhat hot with rye-spice and oak, along with vanilla sweetness. A few drops of water does help tame the heat and bring out brighter flavors.
Overall, this is a great barrel proof option for the price, but may be a little hot for those who are not used to BP drams!

Smoke Wagon) $69, 115.4proof. A blend of 4yr-12yr MGP barrels.
-The Nose is instantly inviting and starts with oaky walnut nuttiness, along with bright cinnamon apple, some cherry, and a hint of orange peel.
-The Palate has an oily and smooth mouthfeel. Flavors of cinnamon and brown sugar jump out, but then bright green apple and vanilla develop, and finally biscuits with orange marmalade.
-The Finish is decently long and starts to show some rye-spice, along with butterscotch, and mild oak tannins.
Overall, this is an amazingly good bottle that I honestly have a hard time believing is all MGP.

VERDICT) This is no contest. Fancy comes away with a convincing victory. Smoke Wagon Uncut Unfiltered is one of my favorite pours for under $80 on my shelf right now. It is totally unique, and I cannot commend Aaron @smokewagon enough for this amazing blend. Well done! I think I need to put it up against another of my favorite MGP sourced bottles, Belle Meade Reserve, next!

What do you guys think??

Previous
Previous

Old Rip Van Winkle 10yr Vs. Weller 107

Next
Next

Hancock’s Reserve Vs. Peerless Bourbon